“The past is a foreign country,” wrote novelist LP Hartley. “They do things differently there.”
Viewers can follow these words as they approach the “will of Ann Lee”, for director Mona Fastvold has really done so. A work of undakchable, near-pyrical zeal on a topic defined by the same characteristics is similar to this intimate and maximalist musical a little else by year Venice Film FestivalOr in the cinema 2025. Fastvold fuses are formed with function to meet a religious leader from the 18th century on their own terms and delivers an exciting modern incident of an outdated melody.
In many respects, however, the film is reminiscent of a certain American title from a decade ago. A spiritual relative of Robert Eggers “The Witch”, Fastvold’s latest charts of the Okstasians in colonial New England in a linguistic resisting contemporary framing. Without softening the cruelty of time, Fastvold and her co -author Brady Corbet stops without direct fear, instead focuses on the joy born with fear. Such intention comes in sharper relief in the film’s full title: “The will of Ann Lee or the woman dressed with the sun, with the moon under her feet.” Discovering from revelation it emphasizes redemption and renewal – while the huge red dragon with seven heads and 10 horns beating in the next verse.
Or maybe they are foreshadowing, because deprivation and oppression are never far away. If something, these very difficulties – snorting in the beginning and punishes to the end – form the earth from which Lee’s utopian society root and sets the rhythm for a young girl who became religious radical who meets darkness with a crazy desire to dance.
We start in the 1750s Manchester, after a hard believer when she is married and forced to mourn four infants, each lost before her first birthday. This takes place in a musical sequence of haunting beauty, where the period’s hymns gather with Daniel Blumberg’s spectral points and Amanda Seyfried’s devastating performance and signs through her grief. Fans of “Les Miséables” can glimpse onetime Cosette -re -operation as Fantine, and founded the film in a similar anxiety that gives way here for spiritual rebirth. For all its poverty, pre-industrial England was actually a country with promise-aabaptist guldrush for quakers, methodists and all kinds of quakes, each grief of infant mortality and is ointmented by the birth lid of the new world.
Soon enough – and almost entirely through flashes of singing and dance – Ann plants her own flag and comes out of the fertile ground as the leader of the shakes. Hers is a more radical trunk, preaching the expulsion of sin through movement (the name, after all, derives from “shaking quakes”) and staging of revivals such as flash mobs, anywhere and everywhere, much to concern for public authorities. Still, the threat of prison shows less frightening than Ann’s uncompromising insistence on Celibat – a dictum that ranks her husband Abraham (Christopher Abbott) above all.
Although Fastvold and Corbet resist all modern psychological frameworks, the effects of loss of mother’s loss feel universal and promote answers that may arise at any time or place. In this historical context, compliance with dogmatic chastity becomes emancipatory, which gives an illiterate, otherwise socially limited mancunian authority to reshape the world on its own terms. In this social order, contemporary perceptions of identity keeps a little turn – a fact that clarified when Ann’s brother and chief assembly, William (Lewis Pullman), forgets his male lover with barely a word of comments.
Almost all early apostles are given a moment of musical grace, whether it is back in Blighty, on the boat to the colonies, or over a field in Upstate New York, where the oldest converted, Hocknell (David Cale), arrives at the site of the sect’s New Utopia in a happy (and even Disney) toe). For starters, Fastvold is equally dogmatic to conventional musical forms, but the strics gradually come off when Ann and her followers are doing in the New World. The dances, all choreographed by Celia Rowlson Hall, undergo a mirrored transformation, with the early, frenetic movements, intended to induce the transmission and division of pain, gradually give way for something more arranged – almost like a line dance, which reflects the growth and anchoring of this religious order.
“The will of Ann Lee” is a high film about the silence within, almost always chooses to impress rather than entertaining. Fastvold’s approach is uncompromising and unmatched, especially when it comes to choreographing the countless bodily harm that Ann’s vision can provoke. The Venice Public greeted it with both Walkouts and rough applause-surprising, given the self-elected nature of those who remain, of course, to see its broader public reception. But I was enchanted, and many more will also be. Although the shakes once numbered 6,000 strong, today all but three living supporters remain. It can also change once to a crash on this foreign country.
Read all our Venice Film Festival coverage here.
